Carrie Underwood American Idol judge backlash continues to grow after her pointed critique of finalist Jamal Roberts during Monday’s episode of American Idol’s Disney Week. The latest round saw the top five singers trimmed down to the final three: Breanna Nix, Slater Nalley, and Jamal Roberts. But rather than the performances, it was Carrie Underwood’s feedback that stole the spotlight — and not in a good way.
Carrie Underwood American Idol judge backlash grows after Jamal critique
Roberts, 27, delivered a soulful, high-energy take on the Marvin Gaye and Tammi Terrell classic Ain’t No Mountain High Enough, featured in Remember the Titans. His rendition had judges Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie on their feet in applause — both longtime supporters of Jamal’s vocal talent. Underwood, however, stayed seated, offering a polite smile before delivering feedback that many viewers deemed unnecessarily harsh.
She acknowledged his vocal strength, saying, “You have an incredible voice,” before shifting tone. “But I think you missed a big opportunity to command the stage,” she added. “We’re near the end now, and you’ve got to give it everything. Don’t hold back — make sure we feel it with your whole presence, not just your voice.”
Fans quickly reacted online, accusing Underwood of holding Jamal to a different standard than the other contestants.
“Why does he have to move, but others get praise for standing still?” one user posted. Another mentioned, “John Foster literally sat through his song, and she loved it. Why was Jamal singled out?”
Carrie Underwood American Idol judge backlash calls for change
The criticism snowballed across social platforms, with some fans calling for Underwood to be replaced on the judging panel next season. Comments ranged from “She was out of line” to “We need a more fair and encouraging judge.”
Underwood’s demeanor during Jamal’s performance also drew scrutiny, with viewers claiming her facial expressions were dismissive. This is her first season stepping in for Katy Perry as a full-time judge, a move many thought would add heart and insight to the panel. But the Carrie Underwood American Idol judge backlash has sparked debate over whether she’s lived up to that expectation.
Despite the uproar, Jamal Roberts secured a spot in the final three and will compete alongside Breanna Nix and John Foster in the American Idol Season 23 finale on Sunday, May 18 at 8 PM ET on ABC.
As the finale nears, fans are not only watching the contestants closely — but also keeping a sharp eye on how Carrie Underwood handles the spotlight in her judging role.
Table of Contents
Source: www.newssparkhub.com
