After weeks of speculation, heated discussions, and a wave of passionate fan feedback, ABC has made it official: Carrie Underwood American Idol judge will return for Season 24. What many once saw as uncertain is now clear — she’s back, and so is the bold spirit she brings to the judging panel.
Tensions peaked when Carrie gave a straightforward critique to fan-favorite Jamal Roberts during the Top 5 live episode — a moment that divided fans and ignited a firestorm online. While some applauded her honesty, others questioned her tone. But through all the noise, Carrie didn’t waver.
Because Carrie plays it real — not safe. The Carrie Underwood American Idol judge, who rose to fame as a winner herself, has always spoken from the heart. Whether audiences love it or not, it’s her fearless candor that’s breathed new life into the show.
Carrie Underwood American Idol judge ignites passion
And it’s paying off. Viewership is climbing, social clips are taking off, and American Idol hasn’t felt this lively in years. Audiences aren’t just watching for performances — they’re tuning in for the raw emotion, surprising moments, and the refreshing intensity that Carrie now brings each week.
ABC also confirmed that Lionel Richie and Luke Bryan are returning, keeping the fan-favorite trio intact as the show continues its mission to find the next big voice in music. But with Carrie in the mix, the stakes — and the spotlight — are higher than ever.
Carrie Underwood American Idol judge leads Season 24
If Season 23 brought the heat, Season 24 promises to turn things up even more. Carrie isn’t stepping aside — she’s stepping up. The Carrie Underwood American Idol judge role has become a driving force behind the show’s renewed buzz, turning each episode into must-watch TV.
So buckle in. The drama’s just getting started. And with Carrie leading the charge, Season 24 is gearing up to be unforgettable.
