The American Idol 2025 Top 5 contestants are heating up the competition, and one standout moment came during Monday night’s episode when John Foster received a heartfelt vote of confidence from judge and former winner Carrie Underwood.
As the champion of the show’s fourth season, Underwood clearly knows how to spot true talent. After Foster’s performance of “Rainbow Connection,” she shared an encouraging prediction that reflected her faith in his potential. “I felt like I had this diamond in the rough right in front of me,” she said. “I had to persuade my fellow judges, but seeing you here now, proving me right, I’m telling you—you might just win this whole thing if you’re careful.”
The latest round of the American Idol 2025 Top 5 featured each finalist singing two beloved Disney songs, with viewers casting votes throughout the episode. Foster chose “The Bare Necessities” from The Jungle Book and “Rainbow Connection” from The Muppet Movie. He mentioned that his decision to sing the latter was inspired by Willie Nelson, his favorite artist, who had previously covered the tune.
“When I hear this song, I think about all the dreams I had as a kid,” Foster said. “Some of those dreams are coming true now—being in the Top 5 on American Idol is a tribute to dreaming big.”
The judges, Lionel Richie, Carrie Underwood, and Luke Bryan, praised Foster’s artistic growth and song choice. Richie remarked, “I love the unique tone of your voice. I call it ‘instant identity.’ I can recognize you within the first three notes—that’s what separates an artist from a stylist.”
Monday night’s results confirmed that Foster, along with Jamal Roberts and Breanna Nix, will move on to this Sunday’s season finale, while Slater Nalley and Thunderstorm Artis were eliminated.
American Idol 2025 Top 5: What Foster’s Journey Means
John Foster’s rise in the American Idol 2025 Top 5 highlights the impact of perseverance and genuine talent. His journey reminds fans why the competition continues to inspire millions.
American Idol 2025 Top 5: Who’s Heading to the Finale?
With the finale fast approaching, the remaining contestants in the American Idol 2025 Top 5 are all vying for the crown. Fans are eagerly watching to see who will take home the title.
